Book Review: ‘The Loneliness of the Black Republican’

Eddie Murphy made his Saturday Night Live debut back in November of 1980 in a spoof of the TV show Mutual of Omaha’s Wild Kingdom entitled In Search of the Negro Republican. The basic idea behind the pointed political skit was that Black Republicans were such a rare, strange and alien curiosity that you’d have to mount an expedition just to find one.

While that silly SNL sketch resorted to exaggeration to generate laughs, a kernel of truth was nevertheless recognizable beneath the stereotypical caricature of the out-of-touch African American conservative the quest uncovered. Ironically, all these years later, there still aren’t all that many card-carrying Black members to be found among the ranks of the GOP, and even far fewer willing to proudly acknowledge their affiliation out in the open.

Why is that the case? Leah Wright Riguer explores that nagging question in The Loneliness of the Black Republican: Pragmatic Politics and the Pursuit of Power. Professor Riguer, who teaches Public Policy at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government, chronicles the awkward relationship between Blacks and the GOP which has persisted for decades, from FDR’s New Deal through LBJ’s Great Society clear through to the Age of Obama.

The author’s cites the “Paradox of the Black Republican,” as contributing factors to the “confusion and chaos” and “colossal failures” of a group not only ostracized by their own race, but never fully embraced by White Republicans either. The problem ostensibly emanates from the fact that the present-day GOP “bears little resemblance to the Party of Lincoln” that freed slaves flocked to in droves in the 1860s.

Yet, some Black families have stubbornly remained Republicans for generations, despite the party’s ideological shift to the far right. Thus, this insightful opus poses the probing question, what does it mean to be conservative and Black?

An informative, revealing and sympathetic send-up of a misunderstood segment of society perhaps unfairly shunned by the Black community and simultaneously subordinated by the political party whose favor they so patiently seek to curry.

Kam Williams welcomes reader comments to kam_williams@hotmail.com. Find more reviews by Williams at http://www.kamwilliams.com.