Live sports fan experience too costly for average folks

And losing teams don’t add up to a big bang for your buck








The Twins has a three-year-old downtown ballpark, and the Vikings in a few years will have new digs. The Wolves want new improvements to the city-owned arena to keep up with newer NBA arenas, and the Wild brag about its state-of-the-art hockey arena in St. Paul.

Earlier this summer the so-called local “Big Four” sports team executives in a roundtable discussion at the Twins park discussed the “fan experience.”

“You got to find a way to engage your fans,” says Timberwolves President Chris Wright.

“We are trying hard to understand our fans as best we can, and what matters to them,” adds Minnesota Wild Chief Operating Officer Matt Majka.

“You continue to strive to provide hopefully incremental value for your fan base,” states Twins President Dave St. Peter.

But is this so-called great experience the four team execs boldly proclaim affordable for everyone?

The Chicago-based Team Marketing Report has a Fan Cost Index (FCI) that determines the cost of a family of four to attend a pro game. It includes: four (4) average-price tickets, two (2) small beers, four (4) small soft drinks, four (4) regular-size hot dogs, parking, two (2) game programs and two (2) least expensive items such as a team cap.

The four major leagues’ FCI are as follows:

• NHL average (2011): $328.81

• NBA average (2012): $301.06

• MLB average (2012): $207.68

• NFL average (2012):  $443.93

What is the four local teams’ FCI? Twins: $225.14; Wolves: $225.50; Wild: $346.01; Vikings: $415.78.

“It’s one of the things that keep me up at night — are we ensuring that our product is affordable?” admits St. Peter.

Perhaps the trademark FCI would be better termed the ICATG (I can’t afford these games) index. Maybe it’s cheaper to go to games alone: The Wolves have the cheapest ticket ($7), followed by the Twins ($19), Wild ($35.81) and Vikings ($45-$90); but you also need to bring along your high-powered telescope since you most likely would be sitting at least several stories above the action.

Barber and sports fan Bernard Walters says
that he doesn’t go to games because they
“are overpriced” for him and most Black folk.
Photo by Charles Hallman

Wright boasted that fans can buy a season ticket for the upcoming season for only $5 a game — that’s $205 — for one person only. “There is an opportunity for everybody to get inside the arena,” he claims.

Bernard Walters, a longtime sports fan, says that he doesn’t go to games because they “are overpriced” for him and most Black folk. He adds that the local teams don’t have Black fans in their marketing radar: “It’s not just me” but other Blacks say this as well, the barber points out.

Walters and his son earlier this season attended a Twins game: “Between the two of us we spent a little over $100 dollars apiece. I can’t afford that,” admits the father.

“You need first a winning product,” he continues. “We got four major sorry teams here: the Twins aren’t going anywhere and neither are the Vikings.” He gave the Wolves and Wild similar thumbs-down grades as well.

None of the four clubs have won a world championship in this century: The Twins won twice (1987 and 1991) and the Vikings won the 1969 NFL championship. In terms of post-season runs, the Twins haven’t had one since 2010, 2009 for the Vikings, 2008 for the Wild — their only division-winning season — and 2004 for the Wolves, when they won their only division crown.

“Nobody has been more disappointed by the way we’ve played over the last year and a half than our organization,” says St. Peter, whose Twins will finish the 2012 season in a couple of weeks avoiding losing 100 games for the second consecutive year.

“Getting young talent that in the next four to five years will be in sync” to be successful, notes Vikings GM Rick Spielman, who adds that team officials vowed to avoid using the word “rebuilding.”

Finally, a word of advice from a fan:

“To get the interest of Black people…you got to do more than what you are doing right now,” insists Walters. “You got a poor product on the field.”


Did you know…?

Forbes recently released its top-100 richest sports teams list. Name which team ranks the highest on this list. (Answer in next week’s “View.”)

Answer to last week’s question: How many Black athletic directors has the University of Minnesota hired in school history? McKinley Boston (1991-95) was the first and only Black Gopher AD — he also was the Big Ten’s first Black athletic director as well.

Former U-M chief of staff Tonya Moten Brown took charge of athletics in the early 2000s after a faculty report recommended that it shouldn’t be under Boston’s office, who was promoted to athletics and student development vice president.


Charles Hallman welcomes reader responses to