Emmett Till’s accuser admits it was all a lie

Emmett Till in a photograph taken by his mother on Christmas Day 1954. (Photo courtesy of Wikipedia)

More than six decades after the horrific, racially motivated murder of Emmett Till, the White woman who accused the Chicago teenager of verbally and physically accosting her in Money, Miss., in 1955 has admitted she lied, according to a new book.

Till had allegedly whistled at and groped Carolyn Bryant, a 21-year-old White woman, while at a country store in the small town. After the encounter, Carolyn’s husband Roy Bryant and J.W. Milam tracked young Emmett down, kidnapped him, tortured him, shot him, then tied his battered body to a cotton gin fan using barbed wire and dumped him in the muddy Tallahatchie River.

Later, the two men were acquitted of the murder by an all-White, all-male jury after an hour’s deliberation. Till’s brutal killing, and photos of his open casket at his funeral, helped spark the Civil Rights Movement.


“Nothing that boy did could ever justify what happened to him.”


During the trial, Carolyn Bryant testified that Emmett, who was 14, had made physical and verbal advances toward her, a sensational claim that increased tensions surrounding the case. She testified that Emmett had grabbed and threatened her inside the store, and that he had used an “unprintable” word when he told her he had been intimate “with White women before.”

Bryant’s Grocery (By Richard apple/CC 3.0/Wikimedia Commons)

But according to a 2007 interview, newly revealed in the book The Blood of Emmett Till, Carolyn Bryant admits that it never happened. “That part’s not true,” she told writer Timothy Tyson, according to Vanity Fair, though she claimed she could not recall what happened the rest of the evening at her husband’s country store, where Emmett stopped by briefly on Aug. 24, 1955 to buy two cents worth of gum.

Till was shot in the head and was found with barbed wire wrapped around his neck. One of his eyes was gouged out. “Nothing that boy did could ever justify what happened to him,” Bryant is quoted as saying.

Her testimony was out of the earshot of the jury but helped to frame the case publicly. “I was just scared to death,” she said in court. The two killers later admitted their guilt after their acquittals.

Emmett Till’s murder became the flashpoint in the American Civil Rights Movement. Mamie Till-Mobley, Emmett’s mother, had insisted on an open casket at his funeral, leading to photographs of his battered corpse being spread across the country, which helped focus public attention on what was happening in the heart of the country.

In 2004, the FBI reopened the case to see if any accomplices could be brought to court, but a grand jury decided three years later that there was insufficient evidence to pursue charges.

The young Carolyn Bryant went into hiding after the murder trial — divorcing and marrying twice more — and remained mum on the case until she gave the interview with Tyson, the New York Post reported. Bryant is now known as Carolyn Bryant Donham.

Donham told Tyson that she “felt tender sorrow” for Emmett’s mother, who died in 2003, but Tyson doesn’t mention if Donham expressed any guilt or apologized.

Civil rights pioneer Rosa Parks has said she thought about Emmett when she refused to give up her seat on a bus in Montgomery, Alabama a few months after his death. The shocking crime was memorialized in the arts and literature, in Nobel laureate Toni Morrison’s play Dreaming Emmett, a Langston Hughes poem, and a song by Bob Dylan.

The whereabouts of the now-82-year-old Donham are unknown.


Thanks to Stacy M. Brown of the Washington Informer and the National Newspaper Publishers Association (www.nnpa.org) for sharing this story with us.

3 Comments on “Emmett Till’s accuser admits it was all a lie”

  1. Every time I read something about Emmett Till, I do not become angry but sadden that Black people were tortured just from being black…

  2. On behalf of the family of Emmett Till and The Emmett Till Legacy Foundation, thank you for helping us keep the memory and legacy of Emmett alive!

Comments are closed.