Ghettoizing Black media takes the fun out of sports coverage

No press box seat for us at Midway’s new soccer spaceship
MSR file photo

A man earlier this year said to me, “You get into games for free and talk to players. It must be fun.” I quickly pointed out that I pay dearly the price of humiliation and disrespect for such “fun.”

It once was fun covering sports. Nowadays, however, media days and post-game press conferences more resemble White House press briefings. Team media relations folk are more controlling than ever; players and coaches are less accessible than ever. During the recently ended Wolves season, my 30th year of covering them, I too often was subjected to media row musical chairs that other media seemingly didn’t have to go through.

It wasn’t always that way, but this current Wolves media relations regime has mostly treated the local Black media as an afterthought, clustering the few of us together in a ghettoized fashion I call “the Black row.”

Last weekend at the new spaceship-looking soccer stadium in St. Paul’s Midway, there to cover the Minnesota United FC’s first game, we left barely 15 minutes after our arrival. We followed MNUFC media relations protocol and emailed our intention to be in attendance, but I had no press box seat, nor was my name listed anywhere.

They gave me a seat in the “overflow” section facing a nice white wall with no way of seeing the playing field. I left without ever taking off my coat. 

Other than the Gophers, the Minnesota Twins, the St. Paul Saints, the MIAC and the Lynx to a certain extent, our coverage is largely marginalized, underestimated and undervalued. It took a couple of “Come to Jesus” meetings with Gophers and Twins staff and higher-ups before they finally understood this reporter’s primary mission of covering their teams.

Then the respect level greatly improved. We politely explained that I provide critical, unbiased analysis and other pieces for our readers, not rah-rah for the home team feel-good stories. I provide a different perspective and context not often found in the mainstream media.

The Lynx, which I have covered for 20 seasons, is respectful depending on who’s in their media relations office at the time. But away from home is remarkably different. WNBA league staff routinely do not differentiate between us and mainstream media types.

The National Collegiate Hockey Conference, which I have covered since its inception, also treats me respectfully even though I don’t cover a specific league team. The MIAC commissioner sought me out recently and praised our coverage of his league.

But back at home, especially with some home teams, my body of work that spans over four decades is instead treated like that of a first-time blogger. 

My treatment lately doesn’t compare to that accorded Wendell Smith, who wasn’t allowed to work in the baseball press box when he covered Jackie Robinson’s first Major League Baseball season. Or that of basketball reporter Amber Dodd, who published in February her experience as the only Black reporter covering Mississippi State women’s basketball in hoopfeed.com.

“I’m not the typical face you see in the White-male-dominated [sports media] field… [With] my chocolate-skinned self always standing out,” she recalled, “I didn’t feel welcomed.”

The frequent disrespect by home teams such as the Wolves over the years has built up like journalist scar tissue, hard to ignore. To expect that I should be treated fairly and respectfully isn’t asking too much.

I only want what Aretha demanded in song — a little respect. But these days it’s more like a B.B. King classic — the thrill of covering sports in this town is slowly disappearing.

About Charles Hallman

Charles Hallman is a contributing writer at the Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder. He can be reached at challman@spokesman-recorder.com

View all posts by Charles Hallman →

One Comment on “Ghettoizing Black media takes the fun out of sports coverage”

  1. I am an ADOS black man living in a neighboring state (Iowa), and just when I think my home state is the worst for blacks in Amerikkka, Minnesota always reminds me that unbelievably there’s a more horrible state for us.

    It should be noted that though the Twin Cities has solid growth vis-a-vis their regional rivals (Chicago/KCMO/STL/MIL), much of its white population hails from small-town Minnesota and surrounding states that are uberwhite hamlets that do not see black excellence daily. Of course, that’s because or social engineering, but I digress. That lack of exposure to us as a people feeds into the racism that’s always been the foundation of this country, and Minnesota. In any case, I’m glad Jim Crow North’s “progressive” veneer has been losing its shine through social media and articles such as this over the past decade.

Comments are closed.