• Advertise
  • Donate
  • Subscribe
    • Become a print subscriber
    • Sign up for e-Newsletter
    • e-Editions
Wednesday, May 31, 2023
No Result
View All Result
Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder
  • News & Features
    • National
    • Local
    • Special Editions
      • MLK Legacy
      • Black History Month
      • The MSR Celebrates Women’s History Month
  • All Sections
    • Opinion
      • Mellaneous by Mel Reeves
      • Word on the Street
      • Reaching Out From Within
    • Health + Wellness
      • Minnesota Cancer Alliance Breast Cancer Gaps Project
    • Sports
      • Timberwolves/NBA
      • Lynx/WNBA
        • 20 in 20
      • Twins/MLB
      • MN Wild/NHL
      • Vikings/NFL
    • Business
      • Small Business Month Celebration
      • Black Business Spotlight
      • Finances FYI
    • Arts + Culture
    • Photo Galleries
    • MSR Forefront Digital Roundtable Series
      • MSR Forefront Highlights
    • Go Green
    • Education
    • Bulletin
    • Jobs & Opportunities
      • Legals
  • Events
    • Submit an event!
  • Obits
  • Sister Spokesman
  • e-Editions
Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder
  • News & Features
    • National
    • Local
    • Special Editions
      • MLK Legacy
      • Black History Month
      • The MSR Celebrates Women’s History Month
  • All Sections
    • Opinion
      • Mellaneous by Mel Reeves
      • Word on the Street
      • Reaching Out From Within
    • Health + Wellness
      • Minnesota Cancer Alliance Breast Cancer Gaps Project
    • Sports
      • Timberwolves/NBA
      • Lynx/WNBA
        • 20 in 20
      • Twins/MLB
      • MN Wild/NHL
      • Vikings/NFL
    • Business
      • Small Business Month Celebration
      • Black Business Spotlight
      • Finances FYI
    • Arts + Culture
    • Photo Galleries
    • MSR Forefront Digital Roundtable Series
      • MSR Forefront Highlights
    • Go Green
    • Education
    • Bulletin
    • Jobs & Opportunities
      • Legals
  • Events
    • Submit an event!
  • Obits
  • Sister Spokesman
  • e-Editions
No Result
View All Result
Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder
No Result
View All Result

St. Paul ‘in a holding pattern’ over rent stabilization

by Feven Gerezgiher
November 24, 2021
117
SHARES
2.3k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on LinkedIn
Photo by Ellie Leonardsmith Organizers were successful in urging voters to pass rent stabilization in St. Paul. But now confusion abounds.

What does it mean? How will it work? Confusion reigns.

On Election Day, St. Paul residents voted in favor of a rent stabilization ordinance. The next day, with developers calling the City to place projects on hold, Mayor Melvin Carter asked the city council to exempt new construction from the terms of the ordinance.

Margaret Kaplan, president of the Housing Justice Center and part of the coalition that drafted the ordinance, called the reaction “a disaster narrative. The corporations and industries who fought against rent stabilization are still campaigning against it, but in a different way,” said Kaplan at a Nov. 17 Housing Equity Now Saint Paul (HENS) webinar.

St. Paul’s rent stabilization ordinance caps annual rent increases to 3% of monthly rent. The cap includes newly constructed buildings, which opponents say threatens the viability of building new housing in the city.

Minneapolis-based Ryan Companies said they pulled applications for three buildings as they try to navigate  the yet-to-be-determined implementation process of the ordinance. This includes the highly anticipated Ford site redevelopment—3,800 units of market-rate and affordable housing.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

“The rent control policy threatens the funding sources for market-rate projects and therefore the overall finance plan for the development,” said Tony Barranco, North Region president of Ryan Companies, in a statement. 

Kaplan said that without an implementation process in place yet, many developer concerns are speculative. “Is there a real issue that is based on facts, data and information? And if there is a real issue, what is the way we can work to address real problems?” she asked.

At time of publication, Barranco was not available to elaborate on what threatened funding sources. The Minnesota Multi Housing Coalition, strong opponents to the ordinance prior to elections, said they are not doing interviews at this time. The St. Paul Office of Planning and Economic Development also did not have data on how many housing projects are still continuing. 

Early in September the Center for Urban and Regional Affairs (CURA) released a rent stabilization report for Minneapolis that found little evidence that rent control policies negatively impact new construction. It said construction rates were instead “highly dependent on localized economic cycles and credit markets.”

HENS Campaign Manager Tram Hoang noted that with St. Paul’s most racially and economically diverse wards voting yes on the ordinance, any changes to the plan would require community engagement. “It’s…inherently racist for folks to be saying that the people didn’t know what they voted for. That voters are too dumb to understand housing policy.”

- ADVERTISEMENT -

An issue of process

Without much precedent before them, St. Paul City officials are still trying to figure out what a rent control ordinance means and how to make it work for everyone. At a meeting after Election Day, St. Paul City Council members echoed community confusion and frustration about a lack of answers around implementation and related budget or administrative needs, given that the City had the ordinance language available to them for months prior.

 “That we have done none of this work is shocking to me,” said Councilmember Amy Brendmoen. In an email to the MSR, she said about the implementation process: “Right now we’re sort of in a holding pattern waiting to hear back from the city attorney‘s office and considering options.”

“We’re in a bit of a unique circumstance here,” said Deputy City Attorney Rachel Tierney to the council in an October meeting. With little case law to draw from, she said in coming weeks the office will be examining proposed changes and drawing examples from similar ordinances across the country “with the lens of making sure that we haven’t altered the will of the voters.”

She pointed to confusing points like the ordinance language calling for May 2022 implementation whereas the St. Paul City Charter calls for ordinances to go into effect the day after a vote. Tierney said amendments or supplements—like Mayor Carter’s new-construction exemption—run the risk of litigation and a court ruling overturning the action, which they want to avoid.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Like the HENS organizers, City officials acknowledged possibly conflicting goals.  Department of Planning and Economic Development Director Nicolle Goodman, at a Nov. 3 city council meeting, said, “We need to build the table around the conversation to discuss how to balance those goals of both equity and growth. 

“We’ll be inviting stakeholders, stakeholder groups, starting with city council, to earnestly participate in the conversation that doesn’t pit renters against landlords, doesn’t pit growth against equity and affordability.” 

HENS organizers encourage St. Paul renters facing rent hikes before the May implementation deadline to reach out to housing advocates to share their experiences: https://www.housingequitystp.org/rent_hike_form.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Support Black local news

Help amplify Black voices by donating to the MSR. Your contribution enables critical coverage of issues affecting the community and empowers authentic storytelling.

Donate Now!

ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Jury finds all three defendants guilty of murdering Ahmaud Arbery

Next Post

Mitch’s Fab Five Photos

Feven Gerezgiher

You Might Also Like

Directors sought for St. Paul parks/recreation, safety/inspections
Bulletin

St. Paul Audit Committee invites public input on City services 

Transcripts of Yia Xiong deadly encounter with St. Paul police raise more questions
Local

Transcripts of Yia Xiong deadly encounter with St. Paul police raise more questions

St. Paul’s Highland Park High School celebrated iftar during Ramadan  
Local

St. Paul’s Highland Park High School celebrated iftar during Ramadan  

Outstanding players in Minneapolis and St. Paul
Sports

Outstanding players in Minneapolis and St. Paul

St. Paul joins a national movement to explore reparations for America’s original sin
Local

St. Paul joins a national movement to explore reparations for America’s original sin

Contrasting visions vie for the future of I-94
Local

Contrasting visions vie for the future of I-94

Next Post
Mitch’s Fab Five Photos

Mitch’s Fab Five Photos

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
ADVERTISEMENT

The Latest News

Bees can learn, remember, think and make decisions

Bees can learn, remember, think and make decisions

Black woman shopping for produce

The impact of food insecurity on Black women’s mental health

Plenty of action at St. Paul City Conference track and field meet

Plenty of action at St. Paul City Conference track and field meet

 Lynx rookie forward finds much to learn

 Lynx rookie forward finds much to learn

Call of the wild: Hunting for edible mushrooms is not just a White man’s hobby 

Call of the wild: Hunting for edible mushrooms is not just a White man’s hobby 

One Minnesota’s transformative budget

One Minnesota’s transformative budget

Minneapolis
◉
88°
Fair
5:30 am8:51 pm CDT
ThuFriSatSunMon
90/68°F
86/66°F
88/68°F
90/66°F
91/66°F
Weather forecast Minneapolis, Minnesota ▸
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Upcoming Events

Apr 6
April 6 @ 7:30 pm-June 3 @ 9:00 pm Recurring

Wit by Margaret Edson

Apr 14
April 14 @ 9:00 am-August 12 @ 5:00 pm

Paper Is People: Decolonizing Global Paper Cultures

May 31
10:00 am-4:00 pm Recurring

Preserving Nature Photos by Walter Griffin: REFLECTIONS

Jun 1
5:00 pm-7:00 pm

Metro State University one 1 Open House

View Calendar

Read our latest e-Edition!

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Subscribe

  • Home/Office Delivery
  • Weekly e-newsletter
  • e-Editions

Support

  • Donate
  • Subscribe
  • MSR Newsstand Locations

Connect

  • About
    • MSR Staff
  • Contact
  • Send a news tip
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms

© 2023 Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder

No Result
View All Result
  • News & Features
    • Local
    • National
  • All Sections
    • Arts & Culture
    • Health & Wellness
      • MN Cancer Alliance Breast Cancer Gaps Project
    • Business
      • Black Business Spotlight
      • Finances FYI
      • Small Business Month Celebration
    • Opinion
    • Sports
  • Events
  • Obits
  • Sister Spokesman
  • Donate
  • Subscribe

© 2023 Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder

 

Loading Comments...