This should never have happened

On Nov. 5, Shavelle Devinee filed a charge of discrimination with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights against a Faribault Burger King after an employee served her at the drive-thru wearing blackface on Halloween. Devinee recorded the encounter because she thought no one would believe it, and the video spread widely. Her attorney, David Schlesinger of Schlesinger Kaster PLLC, says the restaurant is responsible because employees act as the company’s agents. He links the incident to a broader rise in open racism. The restaurant has three weeks to respond and declined MSR’s request for comment. The process can take up to a year.

A Faribault Burger King employee wears blackface at the restaurant’s drive-thru on Halloween, Oct. 31, in a screenshot from a video recorded by Shavelle Devinee. Devinee filed a charge of discrimination against the restaurant with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights on Nov. 5 Credit: Screenshot of video

A woman who filmed a Faribault Burger King employee wearing blackface on Halloween has filed a charge of discrimination against the restaurant with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights.

Shavelle Devinee filed the charge Nov. 5, after her video of the encounter at the restaurant’s drive-thru spread widely online.

“This should never have happened,” Devinee said in a Nov. 5 press release announcing the charge. “Blackface is not simply a Halloween costume, a joke, or a harmless form of entertainment. It carries a deeply painful history rooted in racism, humiliation, discrimination, and the dehumanization of African Americans.”

In the video, Devinee asks the employee at the drive-thru window to repeat what she had said when Devinee asked about the blackface. “I’m just Black today … I just wanted to be Black,” the employee responds.

“She was really shocked that she’s just going through her day, and then all of a sudden, she’s confronted with somebody wearing this symbol of hatred and racism from the old times, and it was very jarring for her,” said Devinee’s attorney, David Schlesinger of Schlesinger Kaster PLLC.

Schlesinger said Devinee started recording because she didn’t think anyone would believe what had happened. “She has this conversation with this woman, and then she’s like, ‘Nobody’s gonna believe this,’” he told the MSR. “So that’s why she took the video, and what you see on the video is them repeating the conversation they had just had.”

Although the employee is the one seen in blackface, the charge names the restaurant. Schlesinger said that’s because an employee on the job acts as the company’s agent.

“So here she is, she’s out there wearing this blackface, and their management is responsible for her,” he said. “They need to be aware of what their employees are doing, and if they’re discriminating against somebody blatantly, that’s on the business. That’s the business’ responsibility. That’s how the law sees it.”

Schlesinger said he sees the Faribault video as part of a broader rise in open displays of racism. In another recent case, three University of Mississippi students were captured Nov. 6 on a doorbell camera making monkey gestures and sounds outside a Black student’s apartment.

“I almost felt like there’s something audacious about what she’s doing. Right? She’s like going, ‘I can get away with this,’” Schlesinger said of the Burger King employee. “By virtue of her doing that, she’s like daring anybody to do anything about it. That’s a threatening thing to do. Because we have these rules in our society, like don’t discriminate against people, and here she is, going, ‘Oh yeah? Watch me.’ And so it’s really kind of scary.”

Schlesinger believes President Donald Trump has contributed to that climate.

“Trump made it OK to say things that previously weren’t OK. It’s a reaction to ‘wokeism,’” he said. “People thought for a long time, ‘You can’t say certain things,’ and you still shouldn’t be able to say racist stuff, obviously. But there are some bigots out there that all felt very restricted by that, and now because Trump is president, they feel like they can do that again.”

The restaurant has three weeks to respond to the charge, and the process can take up to a year, Schlesinger said. If the restaurant is found responsible, he said, it could be liable for compensatory damages for emotional distress as well as punitive damages, and Devinee could pursue a civil lawsuit.

Schlesinger said he has not been told whether the employee still works at the restaurant. When the MSR called the Faribault location for comment, the restaurant declined.

“I should not have had to explain to an employee serving customers why what she was doing was offensive,” Devinee said. “And I should not have been put in that position simply because I went to Burger King that day.”

Schlesinger said they plan to find out who at the restaurant knew about the employee’s costume and when.

“This is completely impermissible in our society to do this, and we take it super seriously. We’re going to push this, and we’re going to get to the bottom of who knew about this when, for how long, and how the heck they were so hateful or careless that they would allow this to happen,” he said. “We’re going to show that there’s a remedy here. There’s something that’s to be done under the laws of Minnesota to stop this sort of thing.”

Izzy Canizares is a contributing writer for the Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder. He welcomes reader responses at isabellacani0102@gmail.com.

Leave a comment