Op-Ed: Black Authors Belong in American Classrooms. Parents Can Make Lawmakers Act.

In this op-ed, first published in The Root, Dr. Shauna D.A. Knox writes that PEN America documented a record 11,982 school book bans in the 2025-26 school year, including the removal of Toni Morrisonโ€™s โ€œThe Bluest Eyeโ€ from Georgiaโ€™s Cobb County school libraries. With Black writers already underrepresented in classroom books, she says each ban further shrinks studentsโ€™ access to Black voices. Using behavioral economics, Knox explains how a โ€œbookshelf defaultโ€ keeps banned books gone. With new legislators taking office in January, she urges parents to call lawmakers and education committee chairs, request their districtโ€™s list of banned books and ask school boards to vote publicly to restore them.

Credit: Getty Images

One month before the Nov. 3 midterm elections, PEN America, a nonprofit founded in 1922 that champions free expression and literature, documented a record 11,982 school book bans in the 2025-26 school year. By PEN Americaโ€™s definition, a district has banned a book whenever it removes the book from classrooms, school libraries or the curriculum, or restricts studentsโ€™ access to it. In September, the superintendent of Georgiaโ€™s Cobb County School District announced that Toni Morrisonโ€™s โ€œThe Bluest Eye,โ€ the 1970 novel about a young Black girl who longs for blue eyes, would be removed from school library shelves.

Make no mistake: A ban decides what counts as knowledge and which writers a school deems worth knowing. The Education Trust found that white writers and illustrators created nearly seven times as many English language arts books as Black writers and illustrators, so every novel by a Black author that a district removes further diminishes an already paltry share of Black writing.

The learning cost is real. Stanford researchers found that San Francisco ninth graders encouraged to take an ethnic studies course raised attendance by 21 percentage points and grade point averages by 1.4 points, with significant gains in math and science.

Behavioral economics explains why a ban, once in place, tends to stay in place. People overwhelmingly accept whatever option an institution sets in advance, which economists call the default. When one company began automatically enrolling new employees in its retirement plan, Brigitte Madrian and Dennis Shea found in 2001 that participation jumped by 48 percentage points. Book bans follow the same pattern, which I call the bookshelf default: Once a district removes a book, it stays gone until a parent, teacher or student mounts the effort to restore it.

Any Black parent who has watched a book by a Black author or about Black life vanish from a classroom knows the private arithmetic that follows: fight the district alone, buy the book for their own family or stay silent. The Nov. 3 election opened a path out of that arithmetic, because voters in 46 states filled 6,139 state legislative seats, and most legislatures convene in January.

Parents should call their state senator and state representative and ask both to sponsor a bill with three provisions: a prohibition on removing any school book because of the authorโ€™s race, origin or background; a requirement that challenged books stay in schools until review ends; and a named state office that investigates every complaint and withholds state education funding from any district that breaks the law.

A sponsor alone cannot pass a bill. In most states, the chair of each chamberโ€™s education committee decides which bills receive a hearing, so parents should also call those chairs and ask them to schedule one.

What can a parent do to return banned books to a local school before the holiday break? File a public records request with the school district for the full list of banned books. Then ask the school board to restore every title on that list, and insist that the board vote in public.

The question before every newly seated legislature in January is whether Black authors belong in an American education. The answer lies within our power as Black parents, because the legislators who will decide that question answer to us.

This op-ed appeared first in The Root. It has been edited for style and length. For the original, visit https://www.theroot.com/post-midterms-black-parents-hold-the-key-to-defeating-2000134876. Dr. Shauna D.A. Knox is a contributing writer for The Root.ย 

Editorโ€™s note: Minnesota is among the states that already restrict book bans. A 2024 state law prohibits public and school libraries from removing or restricting access to books based solely on their viewpoint or the ideas they convey. Minnesota parents can use the steps above to make sure their districts follow it.

Leave a comment