Minneapolis Data Center Moratorium Ends With No New Rules After Veto Override Fails

The Minneapolis City Council fell short Nov. 20 in its 7-5 vote to override Mayor Jacob Frey’s veto of a data center ordinance, leaving the city with no new rules as its six-month moratorium ends Nov. 21. The ordinance would have limited data centers to existing downtown buildings, capped their size, required energy and water disclosure and created overlay districts requiring council approval for each site. Frey said those changes amounted to a de facto ban and would create inconsistent rules. Council members including Jamal Osman warned data centers can now move in with almost no limits. Advocates cited energy and water use. Data centers now fall back under existing zoning rules.

Credit: MSR file photo

Minneapolis is set to lose its temporary limits on new data centers this weekend with no new rules in place, after the City Council failed Nov. 20 to override Mayor Jacob Frey’s veto of a data center ordinance.

The override vote failed 7-5. The council needed nine votes to overturn the mayor’s action. The city’s six-month moratorium on data centers ends Nov. 21, and the city council says it can’t enact another one.

After the vote, council members debated whether to try to pass new rules before the deadline. “Right now as we stand, there is no regulation on data centers,” Council Vice President Jamal Osman said during the meeting, according to CBS Minnesota. Ward 9 Council Member Jason Chavez warned that without action, “It is going to be open season everywhere else.”

If no new rules pass before the moratorium expires, data centers fall back under the city’s existing zoning code, which allows them with a permit in 10 of the city’s 15 zoning districts.

The council approved the ordinance 7-6 on Nov. 12, after a proposal to ban new data centers outright failed 6-7. The ordinance would have allowed data centers in existing buildings in two downtown zones while creating an overlay district and capping their size, and it required disclosure of energy and water use. The overlay district meant the council would have to approve each new data center.

Frey vetoed the ordinance Nov. 19. In his veto letter, he said the staff recommendation the council started with is “one of the strictest data center regulatory frameworks in the country,” and that the council’s late amendments “result in a de facto ban.”

He objected most to requiring a separate overlay district for each site, writing that it “would create inconsistent rules for everyone, including residents, and would lead to arbitrary rule making.” He also argued that downtown needs commercial development to ease the city’s “property tax crunch.”

In a statement to the MSR, Frey said: “I look forward to quickly developing a thoughtful policy that supports economic development and our property tax base while addressing community concerns around noise and energy use.”

In an email to media Nov. 20, Frey’s press secretary, Jennifer Lor, said the staff framework, which the council’s Committee of the Whole approved Nov. 10, would have restricted new data centers to existing downtown buildings, required them to share buildings with other uses, limited server space, encouraged renewable energy and required disclosure of energy, water and generator use. The overlay district, she said, came from an amendment by Council Member Robin Wonsley that failed in committee and was added before the final vote.

Lor disputed suggestions that the staff approach would shut residents out. Data centers would still need a conditional use permit, which triggers a public hearing, she wrote. “Primary zoning is not the equivalent of ‘as of right’ development.”

Minneapolis Downtown Council CEO Adam Duininck, who urged Frey to veto the ordinance, told the MSR the main concern for developers is predictability.

“Capital flows toward certainty,” Duininck said. “When approval ultimately depends on a discretionary vote of a city council, uncertainty increases substantially.”

Ward 8 Council Member Soren Stevenson, who voted for the ordinance, said in a Facebook post Nov. 19 that the council had turned to regulation only after a full ban failed.

“When the ban didn’t pass, we voted for a regulatory framework that offers protections and ensures that community members will at least have a say in data center proposals,” Stevenson wrote. He called the veto “one of the most dangerous I have seen yet.”

Osman, who represents Ward 6, also criticized the veto in a Facebook post that day.

“That means data centers can move in with almost no rules. No size limit. No clean energy. They don’t have to tell us how much water and power they use. And neighbors don’t get a say,” Osman wrote. “This is exactly what I wanted to avoid.”

Advocates, including Twin Cities Democratic Socialists of America, the Climate Justice Committee and Sunrise Movement Twin Cities, rallied outside City Hall on Nov. 10 for a ban or, at minimum, strict regulations, citing data centers’ energy and water use and arguing that downtown buildings could be used for housing or grocery stores instead.

“Instead of building more affordable housing, we are saying our greatest imagination of how to build new buildings should go towards a data center,” Wonsley, who represents Ward 2, said at the rally. “That’s shameful.”

If a ban failed, Wonsley said, the council should at minimum pass the strongest possible regulations. “We want to make the terrain as difficult as possible so that they know you don’t have a home here in Minneapolis,” she said.

Kai Uehara, an organizer with Twin Cities DSA’s Stop Data Centers campaign, called the outcome disappointing but said the fight in Minneapolis isn’t over.

“We were hoping that we’d be able to come to some common sense regulations, and that we’d be able to get enough city council members to understand that we’re not trying to do a full ban on data centers,” Uehara told the MSR. “We’re trying to make sure that our elected officials are being accountable to us, and that they are representing us and not big tech.”

Removing data centers from primary zoning, he said, would have required developers to go before the Planning Commission and the City Council and “convince our elected officials that their business proposal was the right thing for our community.” Of council members who declined to override the veto, he said, “They gave up their ability to do something today.”

Wonsley, North Minneapolis Council Members LaTrisha Vetaw of Ward 4 and Pearll Warren of Ward 5, and the Climate Justice Committee did not respond to requests for comment on the veto by deadline.

Lor said the mayor’s office expects the council’s next proposal to reflect the staff recommendations. Frey wrote in his veto letter that he will work with council members “to ensure passage in the immediacy.”

Jasmine McBride welcomes reader responses at jmcbride@spokesman-recorder.com.

Jasmine McBride is an Editor at the Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder

Leave a comment