Crime is rampant in Gotham City. Murders. Manslaughter. Blood soaks the streets. Citizens live in terror and the police are stumped. On desperate nights, a Batman signal lights up the sky and the caped man jumps into action, but even he can’t stem the tide: “It’s a big city. I can’t be everywhere.”
“The Dark Night” is the pinnacle of superhero movies. That “Batman” saga set a very high standard for style, content, acting and production values. It drew you into its dark world with strong visuals and plenty of balletic action that pulled you into Batman’s orb, from spectacular fight scenes to gliding magically in air.
Arguably, this new chapter is the only other “Batman” close to that caliber, a stature set by actors Christian Bale and Heath Ledger, director/writer Christopher Nolan, and an incomparable cast and crew.
In this incarnation, “The Batman,” a string of high-profile and sadistic slayings confounds the police. Lt. James Gordon (Jeffrey Wright, “Angels in America”), works tirelessly with his ally Batman (Robert Pattinson) to solve the homicides.
As the killings ensnare mayoral candidates and city officials, pressure grows to find the serial killer (Paul Dano, “12 Years a Slave”), who leaves behind cryptic riddles. A trail of clues leads to an underworld club and key figures: Selina Kyle (Zoë Kravitz), a cocktail waitress; Oswald “Oz” Cobblepot (Colin Farrell), the nightclub owner; and Carmine Falcone (John Turturro), a crime lord.
All know more than they’ll admit. A clandestine world of payoffs, informants and corruption is revealed.
The primary characters are courtesy of DC Comics. Director/writer Matt Reeves (“Planet of the Apes”) and screenwriter Peter Craig (“The Town”) add in additional people who are vital to the central crime plotline.
They are well-developed, three-dimensional, and indelible characters. All spew tone-setting dialogue, the kind that resonates from scene to scene. E.g., as the enigmatic Batman assesses how others perceive him, he defines his own persona: “They think I’m hiding in the shadows. But I am the shadow.” Add in a very timely premise about out-of-control big city crimewaves and viewers will be hooked for the duration.
Reeves’s directorial style emphasizes pageantry over motion. A series of stunning set pieces are peppered with movement, though genre fans may prefer movement seasoned with drama. This is why, as this whodunit nears the three-hour mark, younger audiences may get a bit rambunctious.
But if they wait, and they’ll have to, Reeves rewards them with bursts of kinetic energy (car chases, fistfights, aerial displays). It’s almost enough to make up for any lapses in pacing (editors William Hoy, “Dawn of the Planet of the Apes” and Tyler Nelson, “Mindhunter”).
The filmmaker’s other blemishes include an inability to bring the footage to an evocative ending. The climax swells perfectly, the final moments do not. Also, when Batman glides through the air, he fails to compellingly show Batman’s viewpoint, a perspective that would make audiences gravitate even further into the masked vigilante’s aura and make an IMAX viewing mandatory.
The footage’s very dark look (color palette by art director Grant Armstrong, “Gravity”) sets an ominous mood. Elaborate sets—from Bruce Wayne’s mansion to Oz’s glamorous club scene—draw you into a netherworld. Batman’s armor, Catwoman’s skintight outfits, and The Penguin’s suits fit like a glove (costume designers David Crossman, Glyn Dillon, and Jacqueline Durran).
Props, clothes, locations, and people are all well-lit and lensed (cinematographer Greig Fraser (“Dune: Part One”). And, if the visuals won’t astound viewers, the eerie audio track will.
Michael Giacchino’s musical score intensifies the gloomy, soul-searching, and fearful atmosphere. Creepy sounds (and editor Bobbi Banks, “When They See Us”) fray nerves. This is the kind of tech team directors/producers gleefully take into battle. The kind that wins Oscars.
Pattison has been prepping for this iconic role for 14 years. First, he built a fan base with the teen heartthrob “Twilight” franchise, which started in 2008. The dual role of furtive Bruce Wayne and brooding Batman is his destiny. He commands attention.
Supporting cast members work their spells too. A scene in which Batman and Lt. Gordon furiously interrogate Oz features acting so fiery and accomplished it underlines Pattison, Wright, and Farrell’s brilliance. That heaviness is nicely balanced by Kravitz’s lighter, coquettish, downtown vibe that she displays as the plucky young lady who becomes a feline crusader. FYI, Bat and Cat have chemistry.
Andy Serkis as Batman’s valet Alfred is stately. Barry Keogan’s interpretation of Officer Stanley Merkel exhibits an in-your-face, badass New Yorker attitude that’s so apropos. Farrell hides within the Oz/The Penguin character, shielded by makeup (Kat Ali), a fat suit, and prosthetics that make him invisible.
Dano, as the film’s chief villain, lacks the screen time it takes to build a lasting impression. Ledger as Joker had more scenes, which helped him sear that villain’s image into pop culture history. Turturro’s sociopathic Carmine Falcone works the screen in a way only DeNiro or Brando could duplicate.
Expect “The Batman” to stun mature audiences. It’s not so easy to judge whether this very adult approach, complex storyline, and lack of moment-to-moment action scenes will hook teens and 20-somethings enough to make repeated screenings an addiction—a prerequisite for boosting box office grosses into the billion-dollar stratosphere.
Reeves, Pattison, and the talented cast and crew have created a crime/action/drama extraordinaire, a close to perfect superhero film that nips at the heels of the untouchable “The Dark Night.”
In theaters now. Check local listings for showtimes.
Dwight Brown is a film critic and travel writer. As a film critic, he regularly attends international film festivals including Cannes, Sundance, Toronto and the American Black Film Festival. Read more movie reviews by Brown at DwightBrownInk.com.