• Advertise
  • Donate
  • Subscribe
    • Become a print subscriber
    • Sign up for e-Newsletter
    • e-Editions
Saturday, September 23, 2023
No Result
View All Result
Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder
  • News & Features
    • National
    • Local
    • Special Editions
      • MLK Legacy
      • Black History Month
      • The MSR Celebrates Women’s History Month
  • All Sections
    • Opinion
      • Mellaneous by Mel Reeves
      • Word on the Street
      • Reaching Out From Within
    • Health + Wellness
      • Women’s Wellness
      • Parenting Today
      • Minnesota Cancer Alliance Breast Cancer Gaps Project
    • Sports
      • Timberwolves/NBA
      • Lynx/WNBA
        • 20 in 20
      • Twins/MLB
      • MN Wild/NHL
      • Vikings/NFL
    • Business
      • Small Business Month Celebration
      • Black Business Spotlight
      • Finances FYI
    • Arts + Culture
    • Photo Galleries
      • Photo of the Week
    • MSR Forefront Digital Roundtable Series
      • MSR Forefront Highlights
    • Go Green
    • Education
    • Bulletin
    • Jobs & Notices
      • Legals
      • Announcements
  • Events
    • Submit an event!
  • Obits
  • Sister Spokesman
  • e-Editions
Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder
  • News & Features
    • National
    • Local
    • Special Editions
      • MLK Legacy
      • Black History Month
      • The MSR Celebrates Women’s History Month
  • All Sections
    • Opinion
      • Mellaneous by Mel Reeves
      • Word on the Street
      • Reaching Out From Within
    • Health + Wellness
      • Women’s Wellness
      • Parenting Today
      • Minnesota Cancer Alliance Breast Cancer Gaps Project
    • Sports
      • Timberwolves/NBA
      • Lynx/WNBA
        • 20 in 20
      • Twins/MLB
      • MN Wild/NHL
      • Vikings/NFL
    • Business
      • Small Business Month Celebration
      • Black Business Spotlight
      • Finances FYI
    • Arts + Culture
    • Photo Galleries
      • Photo of the Week
    • MSR Forefront Digital Roundtable Series
      • MSR Forefront Highlights
    • Go Green
    • Education
    • Bulletin
    • Jobs & Notices
      • Legals
      • Announcements
  • Events
    • Submit an event!
  • Obits
  • Sister Spokesman
  • e-Editions
No Result
View All Result
Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder
No Result
View All Result

Is getting a Black woman on the high court more symbol than substance?

by Jon Jeter
March 26, 2022
42
SHARES
839
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on LinkedIn
Ketanji Brown Jackson

Many Blacks unenthused by illusions of racial progress 

Vernellia Randall is herself a Black woman attorney and she simply couldn’t bear to watch the Senate Judiciary Committee grill Supreme Court nominee Ketanji Brown Jackson during this week’s historic confirmation hearings. 

She caught just enough of the testimony, however, to glimpse GOP senators such as Lindsay Graham and Ted Cruz preposterously quizzing Brown Jackson—the first African American woman nominated to the highest court in the land—about her lenient sentencing in a child pornography case, her defense of prisoners at Guantanamo Bay, and her views on Critical Race Theory.

“I don’t typically watch these kinds of hearings because they don’t ask the questions I want to ask,” the retired University of Dayton law professor told the Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder (MSR) in a phone interview. 

“Critical Race Theory has nothing to do with the work of an associate justice of the Supreme Court. It was posturing [by the Republican lawmakers]; their questioning of her was blatantly racist. They asked her the most ridiculous questions.”

- ADVERTISEMENT -

And yet, Randall’s scathing reproach of the lawmakers sitting in judgment of Brown Jackson does not mean that she supports the 51-year-old federal judge, who is widely expected to win confirmation from the Senate next month on a straight party-line vote. 

What Randall finds troubling is Brown Jackson’s tendency to rule against plaintiffs, mostly African American, in workplace discrimination suits. Of even more concern to her is Brown Jackson’s endorsement by the Fraternal Order of Police.

“What will this actually do for Black people?”

That represents a huge red flag, Randall said, because it suggests that Brown Jackson supports the contested legal principle known as qualified immunity, which shields law enforcement officials from civil suits in cases where they kill or injure unarmed civilians who are disproportionately African American.

“Qualified immunity should be the issue for Black people,” Randall said. “If we want to rid ourselves of this reign of terror against Black people, we need to get the police in court, that is the first step.”

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Continuing, she said: “We’re interviewing [Brown Jackson] for a lifetime job, and so her views on qualified immunity and workplace discrimination are more important than her color. I am not so happy if she ends up supporting qualified immunity, which her record tends to suggest she will.”

Randall’s concerns reflect African Americans’ growing disillusionment with “Black faces in high places” who have failed to materially improve their lives. Across the country, in social media posts, barbershops, beauty salons, and dining room tables, African Americans have expressed an astonishing lack of enthusiasm for Brown Jackson’s nomination.

“What will this actually do for Black people?” a Minneapolis firefighter, Vincent Jackson, said in an interview with the MSR. “It’s tangible for her but not tangible for Black people. Congratulations to her, but we’ve been here before and it seems we’re stuck here loving and celebrating symbolism without tangibles.”

A veteran of the U.S. Army and a journalist, Scotty T. Reid, 55, said in a phone interview with the MSR that he hasn’t overheard a single conversation about Brown Jackson’s nomination in Gaston County, North Carolina, where he lives. “I don’t expect much from her, and I don’t think anyone else does either,” he said.

Most concerning for Reid and other African Americans interviewed for this article is a study by the Reuters news agency that found that Brown Jackson only ruled for the plaintiffs in three of the 25 race discrimination cases she heard as a U.S. District judge between 2013 and 2021.  

- ADVERTISEMENT -

According to Reuters, Jackson ruled against a U.S. Park police officer, a Bureau of Land Management employee, and a pharmacist at a Washington hospital, all of whom alleged racial discrimination because they are Black.

And in the most high-profile discrimination case, Brown Jackson ruled against a group of African American employees who sued the defense contractor, Lockheed Martin. She rejected a $22.8 million settlement proposal involving more than 5,500 current and former employees, all Black, on the grounds that there was no common pattern of discrimination.

“She takes a real procedural approach to discrimination cases,” said Randall, “ and gets rid of the cases on procedural or technical grounds rather than ruling for or against.” In the Lockheed Martin case, for example, she could’ve directed the plaintiffs’ attorneys to return at a later date after they had identified a more concrete pattern of racial discrimination.

“Although they did already have one fact in common,” Randall said. “They’re all Black.”

Others have been more brutal, with one African American posting on Facebook Thursday that Brown Jackson was a “stooge for white supremacy.”

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Other legal scholars defended Brown Jackson. Kim Forde-Mazrui, director of the University of Virginia School of Law’s Center for the Study of Race and Law, told Reuters: “Plaintiffs in employment discrimination cases lose a lot, so this strikes me as consistent with the pattern I would expect because they are notoriously hard to win.”

In a letter to the White House dated February 4, however, Alabama’s first African American federal judge, U. W. Clemon, lauded President Biden’s decision to nominate a Black woman to the court, but said it should be someone other than Brown Jackson. “Based on her conduct in Ross v. Lockheed,” he wrote, “I strongly believe that Circuit Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson should not be appointed by you as the first black female justice of the Supreme Court of the United States.”

Randall said that Brown Jackson is representative of a political system that protects itself by using tokenism—a kind of bait and switch strategy—to confuse or appease Black demands for racial justice. Both political parties have exploited class fissures in the African American community to create the illusion of racial progress when opportunities for most Blacks are actually declining.

“I grew up during Jim Crow and that colors how I see ‘firsts,’” said Randall. “But I also understand that representation doesn’t produce change, representation produces representation, and that gets us nowhere.”

Support Black local news

Help amplify Black voices by donating to the MSR. Your contribution enables critical coverage of issues affecting the community and empowers authentic storytelling.

Donate Now!

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

‘Fast And Furious’ Stunt Car On Sale At World’s First Digital Automobile Auction

Next Post

Black Business Spotlight: HYPE

Jon Jeter

Jon Jeter is a contributing writer at the Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder, who has also served stints at the Minneapolis Star Tribune, and The Washington Post, among others.

You Might Also Like

Federal court rejects Alabama GOP’s defiant voting map, will draw new map that expands Black voting power
National

Federal court rejects Alabama GOP’s defiant voting map, will draw new map that expands Black voting power

HBCUs revamping admissions policies amid affirmative action decision
National

HBCUs revamping admissions policies amid affirmative action decision

University of Minnesota
Local

University of Minnesota will no longer consider race or legacy in admissions process

Republican state attorneys general threaten CEOs with legal action over diversity hiring practices
National

Republican state attorneys general threaten CEOs with legal action over diversity hiring practices

We are not colorblind
Opinion

We are not colorblind

American Bar Association president says don’t lose sight of progress
Local

American Bar Association president says don’t lose sight of progress

Next Post
Black Business Spotlight: HYPE

Black Business Spotlight: HYPE

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
ADVERTISEMENT

Upcoming Events

Sep 12
September 12 @ 6:30 pm-December 18 @ 9:30 pm Recurring

Vic Volare Presents MUSIC FOR MARTINIS ft: Vic’s Fabulous Nightclub Academy

Sep 22
September 22 @ 5:00 pm-September 23 @ 8:30 pm

9th Annual Lantern Lighting Celebration at Lakewood Cemetery

Sep 23
10:00 am-1:00 pm

Expanding Diversity Career Fair

Sep 23
7:30 pm-9:00 pm Recurring

Michhil Amra | We Are The Procession

View Calendar
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Read our latest e-Edition!

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Subscribe

  • Home/Office Delivery
  • Weekly e-newsletter
  • e-Editions

Support

  • Donate
  • Subscribe
  • MSR Newsstand Locations

Connect

  • About
    • MSR Staff
  • Contact
  • Send a news tip
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms

© 2023 Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder

No Result
View All Result
  • News & Features
    • Local
    • National
  • All Sections
    • Arts & Culture
    • Health & Wellness
      • Women’s Wellness
      • Parenting Today
      • MN Cancer Alliance Breast Cancer Gaps Project
    • Business
      • Black Business Spotlight
      • Finances FYI
      • Small Business Month Celebration
    • Opinion
    • Sports
  • Events
  • Obits
  • Sister Spokesman
  • Donate
  • Subscribe

© 2023 Minnesota Spokesman-Recorder

 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: