Film Review: “I Play Rocky” Tells the Underdog Story Behind a Classic

From “Green Book” director Peter Farrelly, this biographical drama follows a young Sylvester Stallone (Anthony Ippolito) from struggling in New York to battling Hollywood to make “Rocky,” the top-grossing film of 1976. Critic Dwight Brown praises Peter Gamble’s three-act script, Ippolito’s convincing performance and AnnaSophia Robb as Stallone’s supportive girlfriend, Sasha. Stephan James brings charm as Carl Weathers, while Tracy Letts plays a studio head audiences will love to hate. Brown says the recreations of iconic scenes, including the run up the Philadelphia Museum of Art steps, will thrill longtime fans and newcomers. He rates it three and a half stars.

Stephan James, left, as Carl Weathers and Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone in “I Play Rocky.” Credit: Claire Folger and courtesy of the Toronto International Film Festival

(★★★½)

He’s punching above his weight class. Hollywood bets against him, but it shouldn’t.

That’s how writer-actor Sylvester Stallone got his classic movie “Rocky” made. It’s a feat that must have impressed director Peter Farrelly (“Green Book”) and his creative team, who now retell the journey behind that iconic film. Done the right way, it’s a crowd-pleaser. Done the wrong way, it’s a tacky melodrama.

The story begins in New York City, where the fledgling actor (Anthony Ippolito) can’t land a role that pays a living wage. Eventually, he finds work in porn films. The money helps, but it’s just a bridge to something bigger. Few believe in him except his dog, Butkus, a bullmastiff, and his new girlfriend, Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb). She becomes his positive life force, telling him, “I’d rather be an opportunist and be wrong.” Those humble beginnings make Stallone immediately relatable, both to audiences who know “Rocky” and to those discovering his story for the first time.

After the couple and their pup pack up and move to L.A., little changes. Their struggle continues until Stallone, now a car valet, shows some of his scripts to famed producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell). A screenplay about a boxer catches their eye. At first, that bit of fortune appears life-changing. In reality, it’s only the beginning of another onslaught of aggravation, indignities and struggles to realize his potential.

Peter Gamble’s script unfolds in three clear acts: Stallone’s suffering in New York, his hardships pitching projects in Los Angeles and, finally, the making of the highest-grossing film of 1976. Every step forward seems to bring another setback. Viewers ride an engaging emotional roller coaster, moving from sorrow to happiness, love to anger and satisfaction to disappointment. It’s as if the world is against the young man and his dreams, and the Hollywood machine is the biggest opponent he’s ever faced. David looks up at Goliath; Goliath stares down at David. The battle is on!

The trials and frustrations the emerging actor-writer experiences while trying to get a project made in the ’70s remain relevant today. It’s the kind of inner and outer battle audiences love, especially when the protagonist has a shot at winning. The result is a monumental ending that fans of the original will remember fondly and newcomers will appreciate for the first time.

All the magic of the Oscar-winning best picture “Rocky” is here. Brick by brick, editor Sam Seig builds the footage into an increasingly compelling portrait. When Stallone’s spirits rise or fall, Dave Palmer’s score underscores his emotions. Sleeping in alleys, tense Hollywood negotiations and sparring in boxing rings feel immediate because Anthony Gasparro’s production design anchors each setting. All of it is captured through Sean Porter’s perceptive cinematography, which faithfully evokes New York’s grimy streets, Los Angeles’ sunny skies and Philadelphia’s urban spirit.

Farrelly masterfully balances comedy, romance, drama and moments of bravura without disturbing the film’s equilibrium. Expect audiences to break into applause, whether they’re in a theater or on the couch at home. That’s the reaction a movie can inspire when its characters fight like hell for what they want, and that spirit holds the film together for two hours and eight minutes. Along the way, Stallone, now a Hollywood icon, isn’t portrayed as a cartoon of himself. His on-screen character never loses his self-respect, despite the humbling and sometimes embarrassing situations he encounters.

Ippolito catches Stallone’s nuances: his speech patterns, distinctive voice and physical mannerisms. He looks, talks and walks like the real man. The film rests on his ability to bring the young Stallone to life without turning it into an imitation, and he handles the challenge impressively. Robb, as Sasha, his supportive girlfriend and future wife, is the voice of reason and hope. Stephan James plays a charming Carl Weathers, making it feel as if he and Stallone have stumbled into a stroke of good fortune bigger than either of them.

Tracy Letts plays studio head Sandy Maddox, a fictional composite who wants the milk but not the cow and badgers Stallone endlessly. He’s the adversary viewers will want to strangle. The character benefits from a sharp screenplay, a distinct personality and an actor who knows how to turn the villainy up to a fever pitch. Add Matt Dillon as a father with the sensitivity of a tree, and the ensemble is strong enough to go the distance in a 15-round match.

By the final chapter, audiences are captivated by the recreations of iconic scenes from “Rocky.” The boxer running through the streets of Philadelphia, punching sides of beef in a meat locker and taking a beating in fierce bouts evokes the excitement of the original. But that indelible image of Rocky running up the steps of the Philadelphia Museum of Art and raising his fists to the heavens takes fans to a state of nirvana. Learning how those famous moments were created is almost as stirring as watching Stallone struggle to bring his signature movie to life.

It’s easy to root for this underdog pugilist in an inspiring biographical drama that wins by a TKO.

For the trailer, visit https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACaWuqeLpSk.

For more from film critic Dwight Brown, visit DwightBrownInk.com. You can also reach him at dwight@dwightbrownink.com.

Dwight Brown writes film criticism, entertainment features, travel articles, content and marketing copy.

Leave a comment